India Boiler dot Com
Loading, please wait...
India Boiler dot Com Logo
India Boiler dot Com
Knowledge · Training · Consultancy
General Discussion Forum

A common space for general questions, suggestions and discussions that do not fit other forums.

Use this forum when you are unsure whether your post belongs to Improved Practices, New Technologies or Troubleshooting. General comments, forum-related questions and cross-functional technical queries may be posted here.

Forum Status
6
Member Posts
6
Comments
4
Expert Replies
Best suited when the correct forum is not clear

Post a General Query

Use this when your query does not clearly fit Improved Practices, New Technologies or Troubleshooting.

Post General Query

Not Sure Where to Post?

Write your issue briefly and choose General Discussion. The moderator may move it to a more suitable forum if required.

Ask Here

Contact Administrator

For forum-related clarification, posting difficulty or general suggestions, you may contact the site administrator.

Contact Admin

Existing General Discussions

Existing posts from the current General Discussion forum are arranged below with their comments and response status.

Welcome Note Administrator Initiated

General Discussion Forum Introduction

Welcome to the General Discussion forum. This section is for general queries, comments or suggestions that do not clearly belong to the topic-specific forums.

Initiated by: Administrator · Organisation: India Boiler Dot Com · Date: Apr 24, 2019
#1 Boiler Start-up / Thermal Stress Comments Available
Use of LP Heater-4 outlet flushing line water for boiler filling during cold start-up

The member asks whether it is a good practice to use LP Heater-4 outlet initial flushing line water from another unit for boiler filling during initial cold start-up. The water temperature is around 140°C and the concern is thermal stress or related issues in a 300 MW coal-fired boiler.

Comments / Responses
Vivek Pathak
Industry Member · NTPC · Jun 01, 2021

Requested more details to understand the operating condition before commenting further.

Administrator
India Boiler Dot Com · Apr 01, 2024

Additional administrator follow-up is available in the original thread.

Posted by: Abhishek Nayak Category: Industry Member Organisation: JSW Date: Mar 31, 2021 Comments: 2
#2 Material / Inspection / IBR Open for Response
Verification of heat treatment for SA 387 Grade 12 Class 2 water wall welding strips

A 660 MW unit is procuring flat strips for water wall welding using SA 387 Grade 12 Class 2 material. The supplier has provided a test certificate but not the heat treatment chart. The member asks whether heat treatment can be verified on the finished product by hardness or any other method, and whether IBR hardness limits for one chrome half moly material apply to this grade.

Posted by: Santosh Kumar Hiray Category: Industry Member Organisation: NTPC Date: Jun 13, 2020 Comments: 0
#3 Water-Steam Cycle Chemistry Expert Responded Rated 7.5
Silica increase in drum water, attemperation spray and DM plant ion exchange sequence

The member raises questions on colloidal silica increase in drum water, why saturated steam silica may remain low despite boiler water silica increase, possible silica slippage in ion exchange systems, and the role of WAC/WBA/SBA/MB sequencing in DM plant operation.

Comments / Responses
Ansuman SenSharma
Expert · India Boiler Dot Com · Nov 21, 2019

The expert explains the effect of cycle of concentration, the small relative effect of spray flow on main steam silica, the importance of measurement accuracy, silica removal through SBA/MB, regeneration issues and the role of WBA/WAC in reducing ionic load before SBA.

Posted by: Mr. Amit Tyagi Category: Industry Member Organisation: GAIL India Ltd. Date: Nov 21, 2019 Comments: 1
#4 Boiler Water Chemistry / Blowdown Expert Responded
Basis for boiler water silica limit and maximum blowdown practice

The member asks how a safe boiler water silica limit is determined, whether the limit can be revised based on international guidance, and how much blowdown can ideally be given through CBD/IBD arrangements.

Comments / Responses
Ansuman SenSharma
Expert · India Boiler Dot Com · Nov 21, 2019

The expert refers to CEGB, EPRI, ABMA and IAPWS guidance, notes the importance of OEM limits and possible carryover concern, and clarifies that CBD should be used as required while IBD should not be used continuously unless sludge removal is needed.

Posted by: Mr. Amit Tyagi Category: Industry Member Organisation: GAIL India Ltd. Date: Nov 07, 2019 Comments: 1
#5 Raw Water Treatment / Clarification Expert Responded
Clarification on colloidal impurities, alum reaction and zeta potential

The member seeks conceptual clarity on how suspended and colloidal impurities, though non-reactive, carry surface charges and get attracted to positively charged aluminium hydroxide flocs formed during alum coagulation.

Comments / Responses
Ansuman SenSharma
Expert · India Boiler Dot Com · Nov 11, 2019

The expert explains the difference between non-reactive colloidal particles and their electrostatic surface charge, the role of zeta potential, colloid stability and how positively charged hydroxides destabilize particles to form removable flocs.

Posted by: Mr. Amit Tyagi Category: Industry Member Organisation: GAIL India Ltd. Date: Nov 07, 2019 Comments: 1
#6 CFBC / Fly Ash Handling / Lime Dosing Expert Responded Rated 7
Violent steaming during wet handling and transportation of fly ash containing excess CaO

The member reports unsafe violent steaming and truck body heating during wet handling of fly ash from a CFBC boiler, due to excess unreacted CaO reacting with water, and asks how the condition can be avoided when wet handling is compulsory.

Comments / Responses
Ansuman SenSharma
Expert · India Boiler Dot Com · Aug 26, 2019

The expert suggests reducing unreacted CaO by correcting ineffective lime dosing, using properly sized crushed lime, adjusting SA/PA ratio and refreshing bed material more frequently to improve sulphation effectiveness.

Posted by: Tejas Category: Industry Member Organisation: RIL Date: Jul 31, 2019 Comments: 1